Diving Into the Scam Industry’s HR Recruitment
Phnom Penh, Cambodia – Before September 2022, Cambodia was a hotbed for scam operations primarily run by Chinese syndicates. Victims from across the globe were lured with false job promises, kidnapped, and subjected to inhumane conditions. Many were forced to work 16-hour shifts with little or no pay, enduring horrific abuse, including torture and murder.
In response to growing international attention, Cambodia launched “918 Operations” on September 18, 2022, aimed at curbing scam activities. A viral video by Taiwanese influencer BUMP, which garnered 3.8 million views, and the rescue of another Taiwanese influencer, Pipi, who was sexually assaulted and sold multiple times before being freed, brought significant awareness to these issues.
While the crackdown disrupted many operations, scam centers have since relocated to neighboring countries like Myanmar and Laos. But what has truly changed?
Scam Centers’ Changing Tactics
The good news: many scam centers now operate under more humane conditions. The bad news: these centers continue to thrive. Over a five-week undercover investigation, we uncovered how the industry’s recruitment sector is adapting.
Casinos and Their Shadow Networks
Licensed casinos in Cambodia often engage in questionable practices, including running online gambling platforms targeting countries like China, Malaysia, and Australia. These platforms exploit the rise of cryptocurrency to scam victims globally.
Jeremy Douglas, a representative for the United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, notes that "globalized crime networks centered in the Mekong, aided by technology, have dramatically expanded criminal revenue streams.”
The Influencers and Models
Scam centers increasingly use social media influencers and attractive models, primarily from Vietnam, Cambodia, and Taiwan, to lure victims. These models, fluent in Chinese and other languages, often have significant followings on platforms like TikTok and Douyin. They entice victims to invest in fraudulent cryptocurrency and trading platforms.
Money Laundering and Technology Support
Illegal profits from scam operations are funneled through money laundering schemes in Cambodia, Thailand, and Vietnam. One of the largest wallets identified belongs to Chinese national Wang Yi Chen, holding $96 million in USDT. Wang remains at large.
USDT (Tether) has been widely used for money laundering due to its pseudonymous nature and the ease with which it facilitates the movement of large sums of money across borders without the traditional oversight associated with bank transfers or fiat currency. Below are some reasons and methods by which USDT is exploited for money laundering:
1. Pseudonymity of Blockchain Transactions
USDT transactions are recorded on a blockchain, but the identities of the wallet owners are not directly tied to real-world identities. This makes tracing the source and destination of funds challenging, especially when layered through multiple wallets.
2. Peer-to-Peer Transfers
USDT can be transferred directly between individuals without the need for intermediaries such as banks, making it difficult for authorities to monitor or intercept these transactions.
This is particularly common in high-risk jurisdictions or regions with weak regulatory oversight.
3. Use of Mixing Services
Money launderers often use crypto mixers or tumblers to obscure transaction trails. These services combine multiple transactions, making it nearly impossible to trace the origin or final destination of specific funds.
4. Crypto Exchanges with Minimal KYC
Launderers exploit cryptocurrency exchanges that have lax Know Your Customer (KYC) or Anti-Money Laundering (AML) policies. These exchanges allow individuals to convert USDT into fiat currency or other cryptocurrencies with minimal identification requirements.
5. Integration into Scams and Fraudulent Schemes
Many scam operations, such as those run by illicit call centers, romance scams, or phishing schemes, demand payments or "investments" in USDT.
The use of USDT allows these operations to rapidly transfer and obscure proceeds, often moving them offshore.
6. Cross-Border Transactions
USDT facilitates fast cross-border payments, making it a preferred choice for transferring illicit funds globally without the scrutiny of traditional banking systems.
It has been reported that some criminal networks in Southeast Asia funnel billions through USDT to avoid detection by law enforcement agencies.
7. Integration into Money Laundering Schemes
Once the illicit funds are in USDT, launderers might integrate them into legitimate businesses or schemes, such as real estate purchases, gambling activities, or online marketplaces.
Combating Money Laundering with USDT
Efforts to counter the use of USDT and other cryptocurrencies for money laundering include:
Strengthened Regulation: Governments and agencies are increasing oversight on cryptocurrency exchanges to enforce stricter KYC and AML measures.
Blockchain Analytics Tools: Tools like Chainalysis and Elliptic help trace suspicious transactions and identify patterns in blockchain activity.
Collaboration Across Jurisdictions: International cooperation is crucial for tracking cross-border illicit flows of funds.
While USDT and cryptocurrencies are neutral technologies, their misuse for illicit purposes highlights the need for a balance between fostering innovation and ensuring security.
How Web Developers Enable Scam Centers
Web developers are sometimes unknowingly or knowingly complicit in enabling scam centers by creating websites, applications, or systems that facilitate fraudulent activities. These platforms can range from phishing sites to fake e-commerce portals, investment schemes, or even customer support scams. Additionally, skilled freelance web developers, mainly from India and China, create sophisticated platforms for scam centers, earning between $2,500 and $30,000 per project. Below are key points on how this occurs and the ethical considerations involved:
1. Building Fraudulent Websites
Developers may be hired to create professional-looking websites for fake companies or scams.
These sites often mimic legitimate businesses or institutions, such as banks, e-commerce platforms, or government agencies, to deceive users.
2. Designing Phishing Pages
Developers are often tasked with creating phishing pages that imitate login portals for popular services like Gmail, Facebook, or online banking. These pages harvest sensitive information like usernames, passwords, or financial data.
3. Creating Automation Tools
Some developers create tools for scams, such as bulk email/sms spamming software, fake bot accounts, or automated systems that can manipulate public opinion or trick individuals.
4. Developing Fake Apps
Mobile and web developers may create malicious apps that appear legitimate but secretly steal user data or funds. Examples include fake cryptocurrency wallets, online trading platforms, or "loan apps."
5. Supporting Technical Infrastructure
Developers may be involved in setting up backend systems that enable scam operations, such as databases for stolen data or payment processing systems.
They may also set up call center software that supports scam operations like tech support or IRS impersonation scams.
Why Developers Get Involved
Lack of Awareness: Developers might not realize the true purpose of the project they’re working on.
Financial Incentives: Scammers often pay well, attracting developers who might overlook ethical concerns.
Pressure or Coercion: In some cases, developers may be coerced into supporting scam operations, especially in jurisdictions where scams are linked to organized crime.
Ignorance of Legal Repercussions: Some developers may not understand that creating such systems can make them liable under various laws.
Ethical and Legal Considerations
Complicity in Fraud: Developing tools or platforms that enable scams is unethical and may violate laws against fraud and cybercrime.
Reputation Damage: Associating with scams can irreparably harm a developer's professional reputation.
Legal Accountability: Developers could face lawsuits or criminal charges if their work supports illegal activities.
Preventing Developer Involvement
Due Diligence: Developers should investigate the legitimacy of projects and clients before accepting work.
Training and Awareness: Increased focus on ethics in technology education can help developers recognize and reject scam-related projects.
Legal Protections: Governments should provide whistleblower protections for developers who expose scam operations.
Industry Standards: The tech industry should establish guidelines to discourage developers from enabling fraud.
Signs a Project Might Be Scam-Related
Unusually high payments for basic work.
Lack of transparency about the end use of the project.
Requests for mimicking well-known platforms or brands.
Hidden or suspicious requirements, such as bypassing security measures.
By staying vigilant and prioritizing ethics, developers can help curb the proliferation of scam centers and contribute to a safer online ecosystem.
Modern Recruitment Strategies
As demand for workers grows, scam centers have shifted to more transparent recruitment practices. They openly describe job roles, often targeting job seekers from India, Bangladesh, Nepal, and Vietnam. Some key trends include:
Improved Conditions: Workers now face 12-hour shifts instead of 16, with 2–4 days off per month.
Voluntary Applications: Flights are no longer covered, but candidates can claim up to 50% of the cost upon arrival.
Accommodation Options: Workers (except Chinese nationals) are allowed to live outside company-provided dorms.
Despite these improvements, scam centers still violate labor laws. Employees average 84 hours of work per week, far exceeding Cambodia’s legal limit of 48 hours per week.
Three Types of HR Recruitment
Legitimate Recruiters: These freelancers or agencies, often based in Phnom Penh, recruit workers for licensed casinos or humane scam centers. They offer alternatives if applicants are uncomfortable, earning commissions of $100–$2,000 per successful placement.
Profit-Driven Agents:Primarily Cambodians and Chinese, these agents care only about commissions. They post fake job ads and mislead applicants about job details, often exploiting unsuspecting individuals.
Company HR:Hired directly by large organizations, these recruiters earn $850–$1,600 monthly, plus commissions. Commissions are paid only after recruits complete at least one month of work.
The Core Problem
Activists and NGOs blame Chinese operators for the scam epidemic, but the issue stems from systemic government corruption. Massive scam buildings cannot operate without government complicity. Authorities often avoid taking responsibility, instead deflecting blame onto foreign media.
Protect Yourself
Stay Informed About Scams: Scams often involve wiring money. Be cautious of unsolicited offers, especially from strangers.
Verify Job Ads:Watch for red flags like vague job descriptions, promises of high salaries for minimal qualifications, and fake profiles on Telegram and Facebook.
Beware of Romantic Scams:Some recruiters use personal relationships to lure victims, especially targeting vulnerable individuals online.
The fight against scam centers requires international collaboration to treat financial fraud as a serious crime. Until then, the billion-dollar scam industry will continue to exploit its victims.
תגובות